EJIL Talk Logo

Archive for 2012

The EESC’s Enlarged Presidency meets

  • Filed under: Work
Thursday
Apr 19,2012

Today was a tale of two dense  but highly productive meetings. In the morning the EESC’s Enlarged Presidency (composed of the President, two Vice-Presidents, three Group Presidents and the SG) met to perform its traditional, if informal, role of preparing for next Tuesday’s Bureau meeting but also to consider a number of more general political matters, such as preparations for the hosting of Croatian observers at the Committee’s meetings and the follow-up to the European Parliament’s draft discharge resolution. There was also an administrative item on the agenda. The SG presented the administration’s five-year management plan and a very constructive exchange of views ensued. In the afternoon, the Section Presidents joined the meeting (turning it into what is informally called the ‘Enlarged Enlarged Presidency’ – who can find me a picture to illustrate that?) in order to discuss the Committee’s input into the European Commission’s 2013 work plan and engage in a discussion about enhancing the Committee’s own working methods. The discussions were satisfyingly rich and constructive.

Wednesday
Apr 18,2012

Today I had a lunchtime chat with EESC Committee member Joost Van Iersel (Employers Group/Netherlands), who is a former Dutch member of parliament and is currently the Chairman of the EESC’s Steering Committee on the Europe 2020 Strategy. The Strategy’s title may not mean a lot to the woman or man on the Clapham omnibus but it remains the European Union’s collective economic, social and environmental blueprint for a sustainable future. My lunchtime guest was eloquent on the various ways in which the EESC is forever seeking to co-opt various sorts of expertise and networks into its own advisory function. The Consultative Committee on Industrial Change, for example, brings in delegates nominated by the Groups (from industry, for example) in order further to enrich the Committee’s reflections on the constant challenge of industrial change. Similarly, the Liaison Group (of which more on Friday) brings in representatives of pan-European civil society organisations. In the same vein, the Europe 2020 Steering Committee not only exercises a horizontal role within the Committee (thus mirroring the over-arching nature of the Strategy itself) but has the specificity of involving the national economic and social councils in the twenty-two member states where they exist. The Steering Committee thus provides the Councils with a unique platform they would otherwise not possess but also provides the European Commission with a nuique opportunity to plug into a broad consultative network with national civil society organisations. The value of the Steering Committee and its network is explicitly recognised in the recently renegotiated Protocol on Cooperation between the European Commission and the EESC. Yes, all eyes are quite naturally currently on responses to the crisis but the Europe 2020 Strategy remains the EU’s longer-term game plan not for survival but for renewed, jobs-rich and sustainable growth.

Meeting with my fellow SG, Gerhard Stahl

  • Filed under: Work
Tuesday
Apr 17,2012

As I never tire of pointing out, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions are engaged in a unique and pioneering arrangement whereby, through pooling of resources (in translation, logistics, IT) and careful planning, the two institutions achieve considerable economies of scale and, as last year’s mid-term review of the arrangement concluded, with considerable success. I am convinced that this success is due in no small part to a complex set of governance mechanisms at all levels, up to and including the Secretaries General and, through the Political Monitoring Group, our political masters. My counterpart at the Committee of the Regions, Gerhard Stahl, and I ‘live’ on the same corridor and occasionally drop in on one another for informal chats. In addition, we meet more formally at regular intervals and discuss agenda points prepared for us by our secretariats. We had such a meeting today and, as always, it was entirely positive and productive. This is not just because Gerhard and I have known each other for a very long time but also because we are both convinced that it is our common duty to make sure that the administrative cooperation between the two Committees works well – and it does.

Tuesday
Apr 17,2012

I continued with my ‘meeting the troops’ series this morning, enjoying a working breakfast with the Registry and Archives Unit of the European Economic and Social Committee. Here is another important engine house in the Committee’s secretariat. This particular ‘machine’ works, and works very well: nine plenary sessions a year, eleven Bureau meetings, servicing the Quaestors, keeping the document flow going… And, as with the Committee’s other engine houses, because it works so well, we tend to take it a little for granted, although I never cease to be impressed by the efficiency of such Units, especially when compared with the larger institutions. The registry is also, as my predecessor used to say, the ‘guardian of the temple’. The registry is, for example, the custodian of the Rules of Procedere and of their implementing provisions. However, as the Head of Unit, Dominique-François Bareth, pointed out, the fact that the Registry must, by the very nature of its responsibilities, be prudent and conservative, does not mean that it cannot be thoroughly modern in its methodology and philosophy. This morning we had an excellent, amicable, frank and encouraging exchange about the challenges facing the Committee, from ever-increasing workloads to ever-shrinking deadlines. I learnt a huge amount, thoroughly enjoyed myself and couldn’t resist a sticky bun at the end! Oh, and, oh yes, much to my delight I learnt that we had an accomplished, prize-winning poetess in our midst.

The EESC Budget Group

  • Filed under: Work
Monday
Apr 16,2012

I went this afternoon to the EESC’s Budget Group, at the invitation of its Chairman, Vice-President Jacek Krawczyk, in order to listen in to the Group’s discussions about rapid follow-up to the recommendations in the European Parliament’s draft resolution on granting discharge for the 2010 budget and also to give the Group information on how the Committee’s administration is preparing for the austerity and reform measures that the European Commission has proposed and that are currently in the legislative pipeline. The donkey work is done for the 2013 budget drafting exercise, in the sense that the draft budget has been approved and sent off to the Commission. We must now await the outcome of the budgetary authority’s deliberations to know exactly what form our budget for next year will take but, whatever the outcome, there will still be two resource challenges ahead: the accession of Croatia, and the implementation of reforms that will include human resource reductions. My message to the Budget Group was a positive one. Both processes are well on track. The Committee is a mature institution and nowhere is that maturity more in evidence than in the efficient and consensual way in which it faces up to such challenges.

Welcoming Croatia

  • Filed under: Work
Monday
Apr 16,2012

This midday I accompanied EESC Vice-President Anna Maria Darmanin to the opening of an information session commendably organised by two of the Committees’ Croatian trainees, Larisa Basic and Martina Stojakovic, and attended by a number of Croatian representatives, including Tanja Babic and Maja Adamic from the Croatian mission to the European Union. The purpose of the conference was to give information about a country that in July next year will become the European Union’s 28th member state. In my brief opening remarks I recounted how I sometimes had to pinch myself to make sure that I wasn’t dreaming. When I first started to work in an EU institution in 1985, Spain and Portugal were about to join (Greece had joined in 1981). Now, the EESC has a Swedish President and a Polish and a Maltese Vice-President – the membership of those three countries wasn’t even on the radar screen in 1985. The successive waves of enlargement of the European Union have been a great success story because, very soon after each new member state has joined, it feels as though the state in question had always belonged and, indeed, should always have belonged. I have no doubt that it will very soon feel that way with Croatia and the Croatians.

Musica Mundi Young Talents

  • Filed under: Work
Sunday
Apr 15,2012

To the Musical Instruments Museum  (Brussels) this morning, to a privately-organised concert to celebrate a friend’s 50th birthday. The music was provided by four brilliant young musicians, including the friend’s highly talented daughter, and organised via Musica Mundi. On the menu were Bach, Beethoven, Mendelssohn and Chopin. The latter’s Impromptu Fantasy was performed so brilliantly that it had the hairs standing up on the back of my neck. But also on the menu was some more exotic though equally beautiful fare. We had the first movement of Henri Vieuxtemps’s Violin Concerto, for example; a Tarantella by Pablo de Sarasate; and Palimpsestes, by Michel Lysight. They were all wonderful to listen to and wonderfully performed, but my favourite  in the whole concert (if I had to choose) was a lyrically evocative Prayer for cello and piano by Ernest Bloch. Somehow, the young cellist got all of the passion, sorrow and hope of the diaspora into this remarkable piece. And not one of the musicians was more than fourteen years of age! The concert was an immensely privileged and inspiring experience.

Wolfram The Boy Who Went to War

  • Filed under: Work
Friday
Apr 13,2012

A colleague’s brother, Giles Milton, has just written an account, Wolfram, of his German father-in-law’s remarkable wartime experiences. Thanks to a kind friend’s gift (thank you, PC!), I have just finished the book and would recommend it to anybody seeking an impression of how the last war was lived by young Germans and middle Germany (if I may call it that). A budding sculptor and son of an eccentric artist, Wolfram was too young fully to comprehend the way in which the Nazis’ ideological grip fast turned to a murderous stranglehold in his home town of Pforzheim, but he could not help but notice the book-burning and the increasingly violent anti-semitism and its results. He was certainly constantly aware of the moral dilemmas his liberal parents and their friends faced, where even minor acts of defiance resulted in major retribution. Though they managed always to avoid becoming party members, the shadows approached… And then the young Wolfram was conscripted into the Reich Labour Service and sent to the Eastern Front. A close shave with death (from diptheria) in the Crimea enabled him to avoid the certain death of his friends and contemporaries at Stalingrad. After a lengthy convalescence, he was sent to the Western Front, to Normandy, just before the Allies landed. After surviving several terrifying aerial bombardments he was caught and sent to the UK and then the US, where he saw out the rest of the war as a prisoner. All contact with his family was lost. Meanwhile, on 23 February 1945 an allied incendiary bombing raid on Pforzheim destroyed some 86% of the town and killed 17,000 inhabitants… There are object lessons in these experiences that we Europeans must surely not forget!

King Philip’s War

  • Filed under: Work
Thursday
Apr 12,2012

I have finished Philbrick’s Mayflower. It ends on a sombre and philosophical note, after chapters and chapters recounting the sad story of the conflict known as King Philip’s War. It was perhaps the bloodiest conflict ever in North America. Friends turned on friends. The native Indians turned on one another as well as on the colonialists and, in the end, the cleansing – it is not too strong a word – was decisive. It was not just the bloodshed (over 600 colonists and 3,000 Native Americans died, including several hundred native captives who were tried and executed or enslaved and sold in Bermuda). But King Philip’s had been the ultimate gamble – winner takes all. He had sold land to buy arms to try to win back his people’s land, but it didn’t work. It couldn’t work and did he, I wonder, know that in his heart of hearts? He was portrayed in contemporary accounts as somebody who preferred to run rather than fight – indeed, he was shot dead whilst running away from an ambush. But what would otherwise have been left? As his death proved – nothing. A few summers ago I was in Rhode Island, briefly. I wish I had read this book before that trip for so many of the places I visited had an older, alternative history. In a previous blog post I described this story as a series of counter-factuals and hypothetical conditionals, but surely settlement by the Europeans was inevitable. King Philip’s War may have been foolhardy, but if so it was the foolhardiness of a last throw of  loaded dice.

Slumdog Millionaire

  • Filed under: Work
Wednesday
Apr 11,2012

This evening I became the last person in the whole wide world to watch Slumdog Millionaire. I know it won three hundred and fity million Oscars and was nominated for two million more, but there was something about the way this film was hyped that made me reluctant to see it. And now I have seen it, and I can’t really make up my mind. It unashamedly describes itself as a feelgood movie and it does, indeed, leave the unjudgemental viewer feeling good. The child actors are wonderful, full of innocent charm. This is Dickens in Mumbai, complete with equivalents of the Artful Dodger and Fagin. But in its determination to make the viewer feel good, I can’t help feel that the film ducks its social responsibilties (Do films have social responsibilities? Discuss). Crushing poverty is depicted as an age of joyful innocence. The slums are being replaced by towers to Mamon and a former slumdog almost regrets their passing. And at the end the Bollywood knob is turned full on; true love will always find a way – in Mumbai Central Station in the rush hour, if needs be.  And why don’t we have a feel good dance afterwards, just for fun? If it hadn’t been for all that hype, this might have been a nice little feelgood movie.

Search

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Tech